Sales Recruiting FAQs for Employers

Last updated: June 2025

→ All answers are written by Mike Basso, CEO of SalesTalent.com — a 6-time executive sales leader and expert in sales hiring and recruiting.

How much do sales recruiters typically charge?

Most sales recruiters charge 20% to 30% of the candidate’s base salary, with 25% as the standard market rate.Be cautious of firms charging less than 20% — they often cut corners, rely on job ads, or lack the ability to recruit top passive sales talent.

Sales recruiting takes real time, research, and outreach. Trying to save a few points upfront often ends up costing far more in mis-hires or lost revenue.

How quickly can a sales recruiter fill an open sales role?

Most external sales recruiters can fill a standard sales role in about 30 days. A strong recruiter should be able to submit 3 to 5 vetted, interested candidates within two weeks of starting the search.

Time to fill depends on both the recruiter and the employer. Recruiters control the speed of candidate sourcing and submission. Employers control how quickly they schedule interviews, provide feedback, and extend offers. Delays in any of those steps can extend the hiring timeline.

Can a sales recruiter really find better candidates than I can on my own?

Yes — most sales recruiters can find better candidates than you can on your own, and it comes down to three main factors: bandwidth, expertise, and network.

Hiring top-performing, passive sales talent takes time—often 80+ hours per role—and most internal teams don’t have the capacity. Sales recruiters also have tools, techniques, and outreach methods tailored for sourcing hard-to-reach candidates. And they’ve built deep talent pools over years of focused recruiting, giving them faster and higher-quality access to specialized talent.

When does it make sense to hire a sales recruiter instead of handling hiring internally?

Consider hiring a sales recruiter when:

• Job postings aren’t attracting qualified candidates
• You need to fill specialized sales roles quickly
• Your internal recruiting team lacks bandwidth or sales-specific talent expertise
• You’re targeting niche talent pools that are hard to reach

External sales recruiters offer established candidate networks, specialized expertise, and dedicated bandwidth that can accelerate your hiring process, especially for hard-to-fill positions..

What are the main advantages of using a specialized sales recruiter?

Specialized sales recruiters offer faster results, better candidate matches, and higher overall ROI compared to general recruiters. They bring years of experience building sales-specific tools, techniques, and talent networks — allowing them to deliver top candidates more quickly and with greater accuracy.

Because specialized recruiters find better-fit hires faster, time-to-hire, onboarding, and ramp periods are shortened. This means less downtime in your sales org and faster revenue impact — making them a smarter investment for high-stakes sales hiring.

Do sales recruiting firms offer a guarantee if the candidate doesn’t work out?

Yes — most sales recruiting firms offer a replacement guarantee. If a candidate quits or is terminated within a specified period (typically 30 to 90 days), the firm will provide a replacement at no additional cost. Layoffs are usually excluded, and late payment of the recruiting fee can void the guarantee.

Some agreements give employers up to a year to exercise the guarantee, in case a replacement isn’t needed immediately.

Should I work exclusively with one sales recruiter or use multiple firms?

While it might seem logical to work with multiple recruiting firms on the same search, it often backfires. When recruiters know a search isn’t exclusive, they deprioritize it — knowing another firm could submit a candidate first. This leads to reduced effort and weaker results.

Non-exclusive searches also become a race to submit resumes, resulting in lower candidate quality. Additionally, having multiple recruiters contact the same talent pool can damage your employer brand. For high-priority roles, it’s almost always more effective to work exclusively with one committed partner.

How do I select the best sales recruiting firm for my needs?

Don’t choose a recruiting firm based on the lowest fee. Instead, evaluate how they source candidates, their experience in sales recruiting, and how well they understand your industry and ideal candidate profile.

The most important question: Will they proactively recruit top talent through passive outreach, or just repost your job ad? Also, consider whether you’re working with a generalist recruiter or a specialist with deep domain experience and a vetted sales talent pool. Finally, make sure the recruiter handling your search is a seasoned professional—not someone still learning the ropes.

How exactly do sales recruiters source and screen candidates?

Sales recruiters use multiple sourcing methods:

• Most effective: Direct outreach to ideal passive candidates who are currently successful but open to new opportunities.
• Moderately effective: Internal database of previously vetted sales professionals
• Least effective: Job postings (often yields the same low-quality candidates that prompted you to hire a recruiter)
• Screening process: Top sales recruiters such as SalesTalent.com conduct screening calls using a custom scorecard tailored to your specific role requirements.

What types of sales roles are best filled by sales recruiting firms?

Sales recruiters are best for B2B roles that are senior, specialized, or hard to fill — where job ads fall short and targeted outreach is needed.

They’re especially effective for SDR, AE, or sales leadership roles in industries like software, tech, medical, manufacturing, logistics, and media. In contrast, B2C sales roles are often less complex and can usually be filled through job postings without an external recruiter.

About This Sales Hiring Careers Hub